Pre-Cancerous Polyps Missed in Third of Colonoscopies Due to Poor Patient Prep
Most seniors dread their colonoscopy exam and a big part of this consternation is due to the required preparation - about a
quarter do poor job
By Jim Dryden
See video below news report
March 27, 2012 - What happens on the day before a colonoscopy may be just as important as the colon-screening test
itself. Gastroenterologists at Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis have found that when patients don’t adequately prep for
the test by cleansing their colons, doctors often can’t see potentially dangerous pre-cancerous lesions.
Reporting in the journal Gastrointestinal Endoscopy, the researchers say that doctors often missed at least one
pre-cancerous growth in about one-third of patients who did not properly prepare for their colonoscopy. Those polyps and other markers of
cancer risk were only discovered months later when patients had their next colonoscopy.
Although several studies have found that up to a quarter of colonoscopy patients don’t prepare adequately for the test,
the new study is the first to point out the potential consequences of poor bowel preparation in outpatients at average risk.
“Because so many of the patients had a follow-up screening less than a year after the initial test, we strongly suspect
that most of the pre-cancerous growths found during the second colonoscopy already were present at the time of the initial test,” says first
author Reena Chokshi, MD, a gastroenterology fellow at Washington University.
The researchers say their findings suggest that if a physician is having difficulty seeing the colon due to inadequate
bowel prep, the colonoscopy should be stopped and rescheduled.
“We often can detect preparation problems during the first few minutes of the procedure,” Chokshi says. “And based on
this study, we would say that rather than subjecting a patient to the potential risks of a full colonoscopy when we may not be able to detect
polyps, or other pre-cancerous growths called adenomas, it may be better to bring that patient back as soon as possible for a repeat procedure
with better bowel preparation.”
On the day before a colonoscopy exam, people are asked to stop eating solid food and to consume only clear liquids. Later
in the day and the next morning, patients drink bowel-cleansing mixtures to empty the colon prior to the examination.
The test itself usually takes less than an hour, and patients are sedated during that time. Using a tiny camera, doctors
are able to look at the walls of the colon in an attempt to detect polyps and other pre-cancerous growths. Once detected, those growths can be
removed during the course of the colonoscopy. Patients often must miss two days of work: the day of preparation and the day of the test.
Recently, the outpatient endoscopy center at Washington University and Barnes-Jewish Hospital in St. Louis has begun screening patients on
Saturday mornings to reduce the number of vacation days some patients have to use.
“Many patients say that the bowel preparation before the colonoscopy is the worst part of having the test, but it’s also
very important because in order to see polyps or cancers, we really have to be able to clearly see the entire wall of the colon,” says senior
author Jean S. Wang, MD, PhD, assistant professor of medicine in the Division of Gastroenterology. “Inadequate preparation makes that very
difficult for a physician.”
The researchers retrospectively studied patients who had an average risk of colon cancer and got screening colonoscopies
in the outpatient endoscopy center. Individuals with a history of inflammatory bowel disease, a family history of colorectal cancer or a
medical history of colon polyps were not included in the study.
In the five-year span between 2004-09, 373 patients at the center were identified as having inadequate bowel preparation.
Of the 133 patients who later had a second colonoscopy during the study period, 33.8 percent had at least one pre-cancerous adenoma detected
in that repeat screening. And almost one in five of that group were considered to be at high risk for colon cancer because they either had
more than three adenomas detected, or the test discovered at least one large lesion.
In fact, the researchers found that 18 percent of the patients who had a second colonoscopy would have been given
different recommendations if their polyps and adenomas had been detected during the initial screening, such as more frequent colonoscopies to
monitor the development of growths in the colon.
“It generally takes several years for an adenoma to become cancerous,” Chokshi says. “But it’s hard to know where in that
sequence a particular adenoma is when we detect it. So it certainly is possible that any lesion we miss during a colonoscopy could develop
into a malignancy before a person’s next colonoscopy, especially if it doesn’t happen until 10 years later.”
Washington University School of Medicine’s 2,100 employed and volunteer faculty physicians also are the medical staff of
Barnes-Jewish and St. Louis Children’s hospitals. The School of Medicine, it reports, is one of the leading medical research, teaching and
patient care institutions in the nation, currently ranked sixth in the nation by U.S. News & World Report. Through its affiliations with
Barnes-Jewish and St. Louis Children’s hospitals, the School of Medicine is linked to BJC HealthCare.
> Nursing Home Abuse,
> Personal Injury
Our Experienced Lawyers Can Help
"We win because we care, we prepare
and we have no fear," Beth Janicek, board certified personal