SeniorJournal.com - Daily News for Senior Citizens

  FRONT PAGE Aging • Health • Alzheimer's - Mental • Nutrition • Medicare & Medicaid Politics  • Fitness  • Social Security • Alerts • Sex Health • Features • Retirement  Elder Care  >Search  >Senior Links

[NavBar.htm]

Senior Journal: Today's News and Information for Senior Citizens & Baby Boomers

More Senior Citizen News and Information Than Any Other Source - SeniorJournal.com

• Go to more on Health & Medicine or More Senior News from SeniorJournal.com on the Front Page

   
Follow on  and 

E-mail this page to a friend!

Health & Medicine for Senior Citizens

Large Increase in Use of Costly Sedation Services for Colonoscopies, Endoscopies

Study says anesthesia services for low-risk patients was more than two-thirds in Medicare population, three-quarters of commercially insured - see JAMA video

March 21, 2012 – Colonoscopies are certainly at the top of the list of preventive exams most senior citizens dread. The good news has been you are sedated during the rectal exam. Now, however, there are researchers finding a large increase in costly anesthesia services for endoscopies and colonoscopies and questioning the necessity.

See video on study below news report, followed by editorial comment on why these decisions are made.

 

Related Archive Stories

 
 

House Bill Would Make Colonoscopy, Polyp Removal Free for Medicare Patients

Groups want to allow removal of polyps during procedure with no unexpected co-pay

March 1, 2012

Virtual Colonoscopies Suitable for Senior Citizens, Mayo Clinic Research Shows

No sedation needed for virtual colonoscopy, but requires same dreaded cleansing as standard colonoscopy - see video

Feb. 23, 2012

Removal of Polyps by Colonoscopy Cuts Colon Cancer Deaths in Half

Removal of these lesions resulted in a 53 percent reduction in colorectal cancer mortality: Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center - see video, Medicare coverage, about colonoscopy

Feb. 23, 2012

New York City Achieves Striking Success in Effort to Increase Colonoscopy Rates

Women 50 plus increase rate 22.3%, all senior New Yorkers 20%; erases racial gaps

Nov. 18, 2011

Concern Is Growing That the Elderly Get Too Many Medical Tests; Little Benefit

Growing skepticism about widespread, routine screening for cancer and other ailments of people in their 70s, 80s and 90s

By Sandra G. Boodman, Kaiser Health News

Sept. 13, 2011


 
 

Read the latest news
> Health & Medicine
>
Today's Headlines

 

Between 2003 and 2009, the use of anesthesia services to provide sedation during endoscopies and colonoscopies increased substantially, according to a study in the March 21 issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA). The authors also found that most of the gastroenterology anesthesia use was for low-risk patients, and that there was considerable regional variation in use.

"The continuous increase in spending on medical care has triggered a debate concerning which services and procedures provide adequate value and which do not, and therefore represent potential areas to reduce cost. The use of anesthesiologists, nurse anesthetists, or both during gastrointestinal endoscopies has been identified as one such potential area.” the author’s write in explaining the motivation for their study.

“Under current payment guidelines for gastrointestinal endoscopies, if intravenous sedation is needed, the endoscopist has to administer it with support of a nurse, and the sedation component is included in the professional fee.

“Involvement of an anesthesiologist or nurse anesthetist, which implies an additional payment, is only justified for procedures performed on high-risk patients. The frequency with which anesthesiologists or nurse anesthetists provide sedation for gastrointestinal endoscopies, especially for low-risk patients, is poorly understood and controversial."

Hangsheng Liu, Ph.D., of the RAND Corporation, Boston, and colleagues analyzed data to examine the proportion of gastroenterology procedures assisted by a separate anesthesiologist or nurse anesthetist and the associated payments for these services.

The authors also evaluated regional variation in anesthesia use and estimated what proportion of these services were potentially discretionary.

The study analysis included claims data for a 5 percent representative sample of Medicare fee-for-service patients (1.1 million adults) and a sample of 5.5 million commercially insured patients between 2003 and 2009, who had either an upper gastrointestinal endoscopy or colonoscopy as outpatients. Overall, 26.6 percent of Medicare patients and 28.6 percent of commercially insured patients received anesthesia services.

Although the number of gastroenterology procedures per million enrollees per year remained largely unchanged among Medicare patients, with an average of 136,718, the number of gastroenterology procedures per million enrollees per year increased more than 50 percent in commercially insured patients, from 33,599 in 2003 to 50,816 in 2009.

The proportion of procedures using anesthesia services increased at a similar rate for commercially insured patients (13.6 percent to 35.5 percent) and Medicare patients (13.5 percent to 30.2 percent). Payments for gastroenterology anesthesia services doubled among Medicare patients and quadrupled among commercially insured patients over the study period.

The authors found that the proportion of procedures with anesthesia services varied substantially by geographic region. Patterns were similar for Medicare and commercially insured patients, with the lowest use in the West region (Medicare sample, 14.0 percent; and commercially insured sample, 12.6 percent in 2009) and the highest use in the Northeast region (47.5 percent and 59.0 percent in 2009, respectively).

Overall, the proportion of anesthesia services delivered to low-risk patients (as defined by a measure of the American Society of Anesthesiologists) was more than two-thirds in the Medicare population, and more than three-quarters among the commercially insured population. Also, the number of procedures with anesthesia services for low-risk patients increased substantially in both populations during the study period.

"Our results suggest that the majority of gastroenterology-related anesthesia services are provided to low-risk patients and can be considered potentially discretionary based on current payment policies," the authors write. "Because anesthesia use is projected to increase further, addressing such potentially discretionary use represents a sizeable target for cost savings. This is particularly true because the number of colonoscopies is likely to increase in the coming years."

Editorial: Assessing the Value of 'Discretionary' Clinical Care - The Case of Anesthesia Services for Endoscopy

Lee A. Fleisher, M.D., of the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, writes in an accompanying editorial addressing the increase in the use of anesthesia services that there are several reasons endoscopists might prefer to use these services.

"One reason is that anesthesiologists and anesthetists provide deep sedation or general anesthesia as opposed to moderate sedation, which would potentially allow for the examination to be completed in a shorter time. ...

“A second reason may be related to patient acceptance. Although it is difficult to conclusively demonstrate a link between procedure volume and anesthesia services, patient acceptance of endoscopy and colonoscopy may be directly related to the assurance of deep sedation or general anesthesia for the procedure, as the authors indicated.

"A third reason endoscopists might prefer to use anesthesia services may be that the presence of anesthesia services transfers the responsibility for managing sedation from the endoscopist to the anesthesiologist or nurse anesthetist; doing so has little financial consequence but may reduce medicolegal consequences for the endoscopist. ...

“A fourth reason might relate to financial considerations. The current reimbursement for gastroenterologists performing endoscopy includes provision of sedation, and the transfer of care to anesthesia services results in no decrease in their fees. With the addition of anesthesia fees, there is a net increase in total costs of provision of colonoscopy and upper gastrointestinal endoscopy."

 

> Medical Malpractice,

> Nursing Home Abuse,

> Personal Injury

Our Experienced Lawyers Can Help

Beth Janicek, Board Certified Personal Injury Attorney"We win because we care, we prepare and we have no fear," Beth Janicek, board certified personal injury attorney

 

Free Consultation on your case.

Call Now Toll Free

1-877-795-3425

or Send Email

More at our Website

 

 

Search for more about this topic on SeniorJournal.com

Google Web SeniorJournal.com

Keep up with the latest news for senior citizens, baby boomers

 

Click to More Senior News on the Front Page

Copyright: SeniorJournal.com

    

 

Published by New Tech Media - www.NewTechMedia.com

Other New Tech Media sites include CaroleSutherland.com, BethJanicek.com, SASeniors.com, DrugDanger.com, etc.